Showing posts with label Video. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Video. Show all posts

Friday, March 14, 2008

Audio Not Keeping Up With HD Video?

Here is an interesting read about how the audio in HD TV is not keeping up with the video.  People are buying 1080p TV sets.  The networks are paying more attention to the quality of their video, but they are not yet doing much with the audio.  Many movies recording in 5.1 are broadcast in 2 channels. 


The article posits that this will change in 2009 when everything goes digital.  I'm not sure I agree.  Most everything is practically digital today.  There are people watching SD with rabbit ears, but they're in the minority.  Most people get their TV via cable or satellite.  Even so, there's still a whole lot of SD content out there.  Will turning off the analog broadcast airwaves make the need for that SD content over cable go away?  Probably not.


This article also highlights the tension between audio engineers and those holding the purse strings.  How much do people actually care about better quality audio?  The failure of SACD and DVD-Audio along with the heavy adoption of MP3 even in its overcompressed form would seem to indicate not nearly as much as we audio types would hope.


http://production.broadcastnewsroom.com/articles/viewarticle.jsp?id=329804


 

Sunday, February 17, 2008

HD-DVD: 2006 - 2008, R.I.P.

According to reports, Toshiba will soon stop manufacturing HD-DVD equipment.  The writing has been on the wall since Time-Warner's January announcement that it would go exclusively to the BluRay format.  More recently Netflix and WalMart have announced that they will go exclusively to the BluRay format.  It's unfortunate because, in my mind, HD-DVD was the superior format.  It doesn't have all of the profile issues that are currently plaguing BluRay.  Alas, the market has chosen a winner.  The format war will soon be over.  The question is, will consumers notice?  Will they embrace the new format?  Or will they continue to ignore the expensive high-def disc formats.


[2/19/08] Update:  It's official.  Toshiba announced that they will stop development and manufacturing of HD-DVD equipment.


 





Note:  I'm not on the HD-DVD team here at Microsoft and have no inside knowledge.  This is just my take based on public news sources.  Don't take this as confirmation of anything.

Thursday, December 6, 2007

Dynamic Range and Color Spaces

Bill Crow, best known for his work on HDPhoto/JPEG-XR, has a great post about dynamic range and color spaces.  If you are into photography or video, understanding this is important.  As we try to aggregate video from more and more sources onto varying display mediums, color science is becoming every more important.  Bill gives a great introduction to the subject.  If you want to know more, there is a great book called Digital Video and HDTV: Algorithms and Interfaces by Charles Poynton that covers this all in great depth.

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

HD-DVD Wins Over Dreamworks and Paramount

Recently people have begun to declare a victor in the next-gen DVD wars.  Because of the PS3, the number of BluRay players on the market are higher than the number of HD-DVD players and thus sales of BluRay discs are higher than HD-DVD players.  From what I understand, the number of HD-DVD standalone players is actually higher than that of BluRay players (i.e. factor our the PS3 from the equation).  Anyway, because of this I'd noticed people starting to declare BluRay the winner.  But now an interesting plot twist:  Paramount and Dreamworks both just declared that they will exclusively support HD-DVD.  The HD-DVD camp appear to be trying to win the market based on cost.  Their cheapest players are $200 cheaper than the cheapest BluRay players.  Perhaps the strategy is bearing fruit.  Neither format has had massive sales numbers yet and the majority of the market is holding back so far.  We're still in the early adopter phase.  It's still anyone's game.


For the record, I still think that downloadable content will probably be the real winner of this generation but we'll see.  The video content delivery system needs to become user friendly for that to happen.

Friday, May 18, 2007

What's Wrong With HDMI

Interesting article over at Audioholics covering the subject of HDMI and what's wrong with it.  They bring up the legacy of DVI which has a confusing number of options and doesn't handle distance runs well.



"Most computer displays are mounted at most a few feet away from the CPU, so it didn't seem imperative that DVI work well over distance. This lack of concern for function at a distance, coupled with common use of twisted-pair cable (e.g., CAT 5) in computer interconnection, led to a decision that DVI would be run in twisted-pair cable."


The reason this is a problem is that DVI and thus HDMI is not error correcting and runs really fast.  It also runs in parallel which doesn't work out so well over long distances.  This is a real issue when trying to create a home theater.  The better solution would be something serial like HD-SDI.  The article explains some of the electrical properties of coax versus twisted pair and why this causes problems.  HDMI is based on twisted pair.  There are a lot of electrical issues with this configuration.  Moving to HDMI 1.3 with much higher datarates just exacerbates the problems.


 

Friday, May 4, 2007

Video Acceleration By The Numbers

Here's an interesting article from AnandTech talking about the new GeForce 8600's video acceleration features.  It features H.264 acceleration.  The article analyzes the performance win from doing acceleration in hardware.  It also gives some statistics on VC-1 (standardized WMV) acceleration.  It compares the CPU usage with NVidia, ATI, and no acceleration.  The results are, shall we say, stunning.  While this shouldn't be your only input for buying a video card, if you want to play video, these data points are certainly important.


While I'm on the subject, here is an interesting post from one of my team's program managers on choosing display cards for video in Vista.

Friday, April 27, 2007

Real Numbers In the Next-Gen DVD Battle

Finally some real numbers showing how the two sides compare.  In the first quarter, BluRay sold 830,000 titles and HD-DVD sold 335,000 according to Home Media Magazine.  Those numbers look pretty bleak for HD-DVD but they are both so small in the overall shiny video disc market as to be insignificant.  For some perspective, these sales figures put the total DVD sales at around $1.5 billion for the quarter.  Even at $30/disc for the HD formats, their sales are a tiny fraction of the total.  The PS3 launch definitely gave BluRay a boost.  Will the Wal-Mart deal even things up a bit?  It's still too early to call a winner in this race.  My money is still on downloads.

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

How Much Better Is High Definition Video?

Moving to HD is expensive.  You have to buy a new TV, new DVD player, and possibly a new receiver.  If you've ever wondered if HD-DVD (or BluRay) is worth it, this demo I found may be interesting.  These are a series of pictures taken from the DVD and the HD-DVD or BluRay of the same movie.  More than just a series of pictures, they are flash animations.  You can drag a bar back and forth across the screen and see the differences.  Give them a try.  The differences are stark.  Here are the two I recommend:

Link via the HTGuys.

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Windows Media for Firefox Users

Microsoft just released a Windows Media Player plugin for Firefox.  This will allow people who use firefox to view web videos being broadcast in WMV format.  I'm not actually a firefox guy but I know many that are.  This is a cool development.

Friday, April 6, 2007

Yet Another Way To Connect Your PC and Your Screen

First it was VGA, then DVI, then HDMI, now we add DisplayPort.  Engadget is reporting that DisplayPort was just ratified by VESA.  DisplayPort is apparently compatible with DVI which is also compatible with HDMI.  Why do we need yet another connector?  I'm not really clear on that.  It is apparently not encumbered by IP like HDMI is.  It may be very good technology but I'm not sure that justifies the confusion this is sure to cause in the market if it takes off.

Monday, March 12, 2007

Why Don't PCs Have Hardware Video Decoders?

Robert X. Cringely speculates in his latest column that Apple may soon be adding H.264 hardware decoding and encoding to its Macintosh line.  Cringely is wrong more often than he is right so the truth of this rumor is unknown.  I'm sure someone at Apple is at least studying the idea.  More interesting to me than whether or not Apple is shipping a $50 chip in all Macs to do H.264 is his talk about why no one has done this before.  He hints at a conspiracy of sorts to keep video-accelerating hardware away from the public.  I worked on DVD playback at Microsoft from nearly the inception.  There are good reasons you don't have hardware decoders in your system right now.  Let me explain.

Cringely says, "Maybe the reason is economic (save the $7) or maybe it is political (Microsoft or maybe Apple are for some reason opposed to hardware decoding). But like a lot of real reasons, I think it probably comes down to hubris and the simple fact that by decoding video in software, road warriors have another incentive to buy a more expensive -- and more powerful -- computer."  The truth is, Microsoft did work back in 1997 to enable hardware decoding in Windows.  The support shipped in the form of DirectX Media around Thanksgiving of that year.  I think it was in version 5.2 of the SDK.  This functionality first shipped with Windows in Windows 98.  Several vendors took advantage of this support.  Toshiba had an early system which shipped with DVD decoding in hardware.  I still have one of their full-length PCI boards hanging in my office.  IBM shipped the Thinkpad with hardware decoding for several years.  Dell offered an upgrade to a Luxsonor decoder card.  Creative shipped the DXR2 and DXR3 at retail.

Despite these many offerings, the market for hardware decoders never grew very big.  Why not?  Because software could do the job and it was substantially cheaper.  Whereas a hardware decoder might cost $10-$50 in COGS (just a guess), a software decoder could be had for something like $1 in volume.  Even on early PCs, the CPU was fast enough to decode the MPEG2 streams for DVD.  A Pentium 2 - 266 could almost keep up and a 333 had plenty of horsepower.  Today's operating systems and background processes sap a lot more power than did Windows 98 but there's still plenty of power there.

Rarely, however, does DVD play on a computer though without some sort of hardware assistance.  As early as the ATI Rage II+, display cards included special hardware designed to accelerate MPEG2 decoding.  On Windows 95 and its variants, this hardware was accessed in a propreitary fashion.  With Windows 2000, Microsoft created a standard called DirectX Video Acceleration (DXVA) which is used today by all DVD decoders to utilize this hardware.  Depending on the display chip, you may get more or less acceleration but the software is always offloading at least a portion of the work to the GPU.

In June of 2005 Microsoft shipped DXVA support for WMV-9.  With Windows Vista, we also support accelerating VC-1 (the variant of WMV used in HD-DVD and BluRay) and H.264 via DXVA.

So, is there a conspiracy to get you to buy more expensive PCs just to play video?  No.  It saves money to decode video without a specialized device just for video.  It is for economic reasons that there are not dedicated hardware decoders.  It's cheaper (and just as effective) to decode video in software with a hardware boost than to ship a chip to do just decoding.

So why then is Apple possibly considering a video acceleration chip in the Mac?  There are two possible reasons.  The first is that H.264 is really, really hard to decode.  It is a lot harder to decode than MPEG-2, DIVX, or even WMV9/VC-1.  Support for H.264 acceleration on graphics chips is also behind the support for other codecs.  Probably the more likely reason is for encoding.  Encoding is a lot harder than decoding (because it requires a full decode in addition to the encode portions).  If Apple wants to do something like timeshifting in H.264, it will need hardware to do it.  Media Center (now included in Vista Home Premium) usually uses dedicated MPEG-2 encoding chips for the TV functionality.

Sunday, March 11, 2007

Microsoft Announces HD-Photo

Once known as Windows Media Photo, Microsoft just released a new photo format called HD-Photo.  Bill Crow has a good writeup on the benefits of the new format.  Basically it allows for high-fidelity photo editing and storage.  While those of us in the normal world do all of our photography in JPEG format, professionals do not.  They use TIFF or a format called RAW (which is propreitary to each camera).  These formats are less aggressive in their compression and allow for greater color detail.  HD-Photo is similar but attempts to be a more interoperable standard.  It also supports better compression than the standards I mention.  This is a technology to watch.  JPEG has some serious deficiencies which something like HD-Photo can alleviate.  Two questions come to my mind:



  1. Will camera makers and photo editing suites adopts HD-Photo?

  2. Will consumers care?  Is JPEG good enough for them?

Only time will tell if HD-Photo takes off or not.  If it does, I think everyone will benefit.

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Display Adapters Demystified

The world of display adapter types is an alphabet soup of options today.  HDMI, DVI, VGA, UDI, DisplayPort?  Which will become the standard in the next few years?  HDMI looks like a sure bet in the consumer electronics space but it is failing to make inroads into the PC world yet.  DVI is the leader today and UDI and DisplayPort are both making a run for the crown.  ExtremeTech has a good article talking about each of the standards and their likelihood of becoming the overall leader.  Their quick take on the situation:  "With DVI so prevalent and UDI and DisplayPort on the verge of crashing the display party, it's unlikely that HDMI will become more than a footnote in the epic story of PC display technology."

Sunday, February 4, 2007

The Sorry State of HD Television

I attended a Superbowl viewing party at a friend's house today.  No, the screen wasn't larger than 55" so the NFL doesn't need to worry.  I don't happen to have an HDTV at home yet so this is one of the few times I've seen the programming.  What I saw doesn't make me want to run out and buy a set and upgrade to HD cable anytime soon.  Sure, HDTV can be beautiful.  We've all seen the 1080i demos running at the stores.  It's gorgeous.  The XBox 360 looks very beautiful on an HD set also.  HD-DVD (and to a lesser extent, BluRay) also look beautiful.  Serenity if HD is a wonder to behold.  However, television--at least via Comcast cable--still isn't there.  The content is often over-compressed and there seems to be no real desire to get it right.


I saw two football games in HD this year.  The first was the NBC broadcast of the Seattle-Dallas playoff game.  The quality of the video was terrible.  When the picture was still, the quality was quite good.  However, as soon as it started moving a little (which it tends to in football), the quality fell through the floor.  There were all kinds of compression artifacts to be seen.  The picture looked very muddy.  I can't quite tell what the problem was but I suspect that someone was compressing the signal too far save bandwidth.  The graphical cuts were, however, quite gorgeous.  Still, this was definitely not something I'd go out of my way to experience. 


The second game was today's Superbowl.  This one they seemed to have good footage of the game.  The pictures of the field were full of detail.  No muddying here.  However, whenever they overlayed graphics, they were upscaled SD pictures.  Whether the picture was a cut scene, an overlay with a picture of a player, or even the score, the contrast in quality jumped right off the screen.  The edges were blurry and there were obvious scaling artifacts.  How anyone could let this happen in the Superbowl is beyond me.  How hard can it be to author the graphics in HD and downscale them for SD?  Several of the commercials too were upscaled 480i video and it showed.  Why you would spend $2.6 million for a Superbowl commercial and then make the video look bad for your most affluent audience?


If they can't get the NFL playoffs and especially the Superbowl right, what does that mean?  It means that it isn't worth their time.  If it were, they wouldn't let this kind of garbage show on the air.  HDTV is still very much in its infancy still.  Too bad.  I was hoping it would be better by now.

Tuesday, August 1, 2006

HD-DVD Looks Better Than BluRay

I was in Circuit City the other day and they had a beautiful Sony SXRD television set up playing some BluRay content.  I thought I was going to be blown away.  I wasn't.  The disc playing was a demo disc featuring snippets of lots of movies.  Each one was somewhat washed out.  The edges weren't crisp.  It just wasn't that great a picture.


Now, we have the first head-to-head reviews of HD-DVD and BluRay.  Three titles are now available for both formats.  The results are in.  The winner:  HD-DVD.  HD-DVD had better quality video, better audio, and better interactivity.


Part of this comes from the BluRay camp's choice to use MPEG2 as its format of choice.  Each of the formats has three required video codecs:  VC1 (standardized Windows Media Video 9), H.264 (also known as MPEG4 AVC), and MPEG2.  H.264 appears to be too complex for anything to decode well at this time and neither are using it.  The HD-DVD camp is going with VC1 and the BluRay camp with MPEG2.  VC1 is a much better codec than MPEG2.  It was invented many years after the aging MPEG2 standard.  It can store the same data in roughly half of the space.  This means that HD-DVD can store a better picture in less space.  Also, despite the promises that BluRay would be the higher-capacity format, it presently is not.  BluRay is shipping 25-GB single layer discs whereas HD-DVD movies are shipping on double-layer 30-GB discs.  Between the codec and the capacity, HD-DVD has space for content that is twice as good or twice as much content that is equal.

HD-DVD Podcast

Our Vice President, Amir Majidimehr, gave an interview to XBox Live's Major Nelson.  He and one of the program managers for HD-DVD talk about the market, the discs themselves, scripting, interactivity, codecs, and what makes HD-DVD better than BluRay.  It's a very informative interview.  Load it up on your media player or burn it to CD and listen away.  It's well worth your time. 


Two versions are available:


WMA


MP3


My initial take was that HD-DVD was losing the battle.  The studios all seemed to be siding with BluRay, the PS3 seemed like an unstoppable juggernaut, and HD-DVD didn't seem to have much going for it.  Now all that has changed.  The studios are still largely with BluRay but they'll go wherever the players are.  The PS3 is looking more like a hobbled old horse than the inevitable winner of the race.  HD-DVD has made a decent showing in the market.  It is available and costs 1/2 of the BluRay players.  Things could get interesting.

Thursday, July 6, 2006

DX10 Interview

The ExtremeTech Podcast for last week was an interview with one of the DirectX 10 architects, David Blythe, and Chris Donahue who is on the Biz Dev side of the house.  The interview covers the new graphics architecture in Vista as well as what has changed for DX10.  There is a lot of useful information in this interview.  You'll get the most out of it if you have some understanding of how graphics pipelines work already but it doesn't get too deeply technical.  There is a lot of exciting stuff made possible by the more generalized shader model and the new geometry shader in DX10. 


We don't do a lot of DX10-related work here in video land but do rely heavily on the new Vista display driver architecture (WDDM).  Here is a presentation David gave at WinHEC a year ago on the subject.  If you are curious, much of what I work on in the video realm falls into that box labeled "DXVA."  You can learn more about it from this WinHEC presentation given by Rodolfo Vargas, a PM that I work closely with.


Let me warn you that the sound quality of the interview is terrible.  If you don't want to suffer your way through it, there is also a transcript of the interview available here. 

Tuesday, April 18, 2006

HD-DVD Launches

The first of the next-generation formats officially launched today.  As of now, you can walk into a store like Best Buy and pick up an HD-DVD player and some discs.  I know at least one person who already has one.  I'm hoping to see what it looks like shortly.


There are 2 DVD players available, the HD-A1 for about $500 and the HD-XA1 for about $800.  That is pretty cheap for a first generation format.  If I recall correctly, that's about where DVD players came out.  It might even be a bit cheaper.  Early adopters always pay a lot. 


There are a whopping 4 discs available right now:  Serenity, The Last Samurai, Phantom of the Opera, and Million Dollar Baby.  Considering a month ago there was talk of launching the player with no discs available, that's not too bad.  It looks like more discs will trickle out each week for a while.  Apparently the first discs and the first players won't have much of the advanced iHD menuing/interactivity yet.  That may have to wait for the next generation of players.


HD-DVD is shipping and BluRay is delayed.  The Samsung player will come out at the end of June now instead of the end of May.  Sony will apparently be launching movies on May 23, but no players will be available to watch them for a month.


I'm not sure quite what this means.  The videophiles are very excited.  I don't get the feeling that the next-gen-DVD war is slowing down their enthusiasm.  What do you think?  Does being out first help HD-DVD?  Will BluRay's larger cache of movies and studios turn the tide?  Does it matter?


I have a hunch that the winner of the next-gen-DVD war will be downloadable content.  More on that later.


 

Sunday, April 16, 2006

HDCP Primer

HDCP stands for High-bandwidth Digital Content Protection.  It is the encryption and handshaking protocol used by DVI and HDMI connections to allow transmission of high definition video content between devices.  In the future, this is the protocol that will be used to connect video sources like HD-DVD and BluRay players and set top boxes to your high definition television.  Ed Felten of Freedom to Tinker gives an excellent overview of the technology.  He describes it in easily-accessible language that doesn't require a Ph.D. in mathematics to understand.


For those who want full details, you can find the full specification and other documents here.

Thursday, April 13, 2006

Why I'm Not Buying an HDTV Yet

   Working with video all the time, I should be an obvious owner of an HDTV set.  Alas, I'm not.  I've many times considered purchasing one but I just haven't been able to bring myself to pull the trigger yet.  Why not?  Let me explain why I'm not jumping in yet.


   First, no technology seems quite ready yet.  Each has a pretty substantial downside.  Second, there are still some changes coming that may effect the utility of what we're buying today.


   Let me run through the technologies quickly and explain why I'm not enamored with each one:



  • Rear projection - Almost all of the rear projection units on the market today require expensive bulbs that are changed out every few years.  I want something that can match my CRT and not require lots of maintenance.
  • DLP [Digital Light Projection]- Most DLPs on the market today are of the single-chip variety and use a spinning color wheel to generate the colors you see on the screen.  The problem with this is that, when things move quickly, you can sometimes spot a rainbow effect on the edges.  Like many video artifacts, once you see this, it's hard to stop noticing it.  DLP also has the bulb issue.
  • LCD projection [Liquid Crystal Display] - There is a fairly pronounced screen door effect unless you are back far enough.  What I mean by this is that you can pick out the individual pixels.  It is like watching TV on the other side of a screen door.  LCD projection has the bulb issue.
  • LCOS (SXRD/DILA) [Liquid Crystal on Silicon] - My favorite of the projection technologies.  It doesn't have any major shortcomings outside of the bulb issue.  It's still pretty pricey.
  • CRT [Cathode Ray Tube] - This is your traditional TV set.  Great technology but way too heavy in bigger screen sizes.
  • LCD - LCDs have very low contrast ratios and thus the dark areas of the screen all tend to blend together.  Trying to watch a night scene can be painful as all of the detail is lost.
  • Plasma - Plasma has one big drawback:  Burn In.  It is, by all reports, not as bad as it once was but it is still an issue.  Perhaps it isn't when watching TV but if you want to connect a computer or a game console, you have to be really careful.

   So nothing quite does what I want yet.  On top of that, there is talk of redesigning the HDMI connector.  HDCP (the encryption protocol for HDMI and DVI) is still unproven in my mind.  Each time I read an HDTV magazine, I hear about some cable box that won't talk to some TV.  Until this is rolled out on a bigger scale, I still worry that the connections will fail to work.  Finally, 1080p is a potentially interesting format.  Some screens (like SXRD) have 1080p native resolutions but they won't accept a 1080p signal yet.  They take a 1080i signal only.  I want to wait for them to start accepting the big signals.


For a whole lot of detail on the topic of HDTV, check out the AV Science Forum.